Ricœur et Butler: Lumières sur le débat sexe/genre, à travers le prisme de l’identité narrative

Authors

  • Marjolaine Deschênes Université du Québec à Trois Rivières

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5195/errs.2013.170

Keywords:

Gender, Mimesis, Narrative Identity, Recognition, Sex

Abstract

This article indicates a reflective paradigm generally ignored in feminist research regarding the sex/gender debate, as presented in the work of Judith Butler (Gender Trouble).  First, I address the fact that Butler’s philosophy is inscribed in the hermeneutical tradition of suspicion. Second, I put into relief the implicitly Platonic concept of mimesis, which is central to the anticipated subversion of gender, but uncriticized by Butler and others who follow her line of thought.  Third, since Butler’s feminism can’t ward off dualism, nor consider idem and ipse identity, I emphasize Paul Ricoeur ’s concept of triple mimesis and narrative identity, which allows us to depart from dichotomies and hierarchies.  Following the path of Ricoeur and Françoise Heritier, I finally defend a feminist hermeneutical point of view, which is differentialist and universal.

Published

2013-05-22

Issue

Section

Articles